Jump to content

Five Star Roll Over Rating Verts Vs Coupes?

Recommended Posts



I have a really nice '10 Coupe, but I'm thinking of selling it for a same year convertible. IMHO I feel the 2010 models were the last 'real' muscle cars, because they came with an iron block, and the best stock clutch. Plus, I don't like unproven technology in the whole 'plasma coating transfer' they give the cylinder bores, in the 11's and up.


I went for a ride in the Vert I would purchase, and loved the sound, and whole driving experience top down! Enough so, that I am seriously considering a vert. Even at 100+ speeds, top up, it's quieter inside than my '11 Nissan! I don't track my cars, so advice against a Vert for this reason is not important to me. What is important is safety!


I did some research, and the Verts get a 5 star rating in rollovers. I was all thrilled about this until I looked for more data. The seller claims that Ford built the convertible's roof to protect in a rollover, to 100mph. He claims they did this by using stronger metal in the bar of the roof. In effect, a "roll bar". I couldn't' find any proof of this info online.


The NHTSA 5 star rating, unless I'm mistaken, is for "roll over protection". Initially I thought that meant, "in a rollover it's as safe as the coupe". Perhaps Ford made the A pillars strong, etc. I have received conflicting information as to what that rating means.


There was one forum site that stated the 5 star roll over rating means:


"The car has strong resistance to rolling over (due to a low center of gravity), but if, or once it does roll over, you are screwed."


How accurate is that statement?





Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...
  • 2 months later...

I have a 2010 convertible and I just try really hard not to roll it. Buy it , it's a totally different driving experience. I have always owned a convertible and have never come close to rolling. I have had 4 verts , 1964 chevelle , 1989 gt, 2000 saleen speedster, 2010 Shelby gt 500, Knock on wood.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bought my first vert in 1972--it was a '59 MGA. My 07 vert is the 8th I've owned, including a 1972 Jensen Healey and a 1982 Fiat Spider that were my son's primary cars in high school.......the JH came with a roll bar installed. We put one in the Fiat. A friend who had done considerable sports car racing in his youth referred to them both as "one bounce bars". If it's not a cage-built car, the roll bar is not going to stand up to a Nascar style flip, spin & roll. Neither is anything else. NHTSA data shows that there is NO tire/car combo that will roll over without first having struck something to cause it to flip (ditch culvert, tree stump, small animal). Nevertheless, there's always that chance. I put 2 teenage boys in convertibles and never really worried about them flipping. I've been driving one continuously since 1972 and nary a flip or ever come close. No, I don't believe it is as safe as a closed car. 5 star rating? Maybe by government standards the reinforced windshield frame serves as a "one bounce bar". Don't worry, be happy and enjoy a vert! BTW, the Fiat and the JH (now replaced by an 06 GT Mustang).....and my 07 vert carry even more precious cargo from time to time than before-----my grandchildren, so I have no fear of verts. Hopefully none of the grandkids will either.......Enjoy, life is short, let the wind blow through your hair while you still have some!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Create New...